Stuck in commercial lease with 2 years left - went fully remote, can I break it?

I publish illustrative scenarios prepared by my practice. The participants and conversations are fictional. These are not posts by real users, accounts of client experiences or reports of actual results.
Started by rebecca_l_13 · Jun 7, 2024 · 3 replies
For informational purposes only. Not legal advice.
RL
rebecca_l_13 OP

I'm in a tough spot. Signed a 5-year commercial lease for office space in Denver back in 2023 (3200 sq ft, $6800/month). At the time we had 8 employees and were growing.

Fast forward to now - we're down to 5 employees, all working remotely, and we haven't used the office in over 6 months. Paying $81K/year for empty space is killing us. We still have 2 years left on the lease.

I talked to the landlord about early termination and he basically said "not my problem, you signed a contract." The lease has no early termination clause. What are my actual options here? Can I just stop paying and walk away? Find a sublease tenant? I'm desperate.

RL
rebecca_l_13 OP

Quick update: Sent the landlord an email proposing a $27K buyout (4 months rent) to terminate in 90 days. Also offered to maintain the space and help with showing it to new tenants.

He responded pretty quickly - rejected the buyout but said he's open to me finding a sublease tenant OR he'd consider a higher buyout number. Asked me to submit a formal proposal with financials showing my company's situation.

Progress at least. Going to simultaneously list the space and counter with a $35K buyout offer.

RL
rebecca_l_13 OP

Final update: We reached a deal! Found a subtenant through a commercial broker (tech company looking for short-term space). They're willing to take it for 18 months at $6,500/month.

Landlord agreed to let me assign the remaining 24 months to them, with me paying a $13,600 "assignment fee" (2 months rent) and guaranteeing the first 6 months of their rent. After 6 months I'm completely released.

Not perfect but way better than paying $163K over 2 years. Total cost to me is about $52K (6 months guarantee + assignment fee + broker fee) vs the full amount. I'll take it.

Thanks for all the advice, especially @terms_and_conditioned_11 and @PrivacyOfficer_2. The key was approaching it collaboratively and having multiple options (buyout vs sublease) to negotiate from.

CC
chad_cpa_31

For commercial lease disputes: check if there's a personal guarantee. If you signed one, your personal assets are at risk even if the business fails. This is one area where attorney review before signing is worth every penny.